News analysis

Game over for ethnic federalism: Isaias

On February 7, Eritrean state television broadcast a Tigrinya interview of more than two hours with Eritrean President Isaias Afewerki where he criticized at length Ethiopia’s multinational constitutional order and the “narrow clique” that promoted it. Below are translated excerpts.

The reason why this area is immersed in unceasing conflict is because of the direct interference of external forces. The enduring bloodshed in parts of the Horn of Africa is the upshot of substantial impact of these hostile powers.

After the completion of the Cold War, we had not carefully understood the dramatic repercussions of the war. The dangerous after-effects of the war have caused internal threats in Ethiopia. The present-day ethnic federalism was not single-handedly promoted by the narrow clique. External powers have played their fair share in establishing such a system for their benefit when Ethiopia became free from the military regime in 1991.

Within Ethiopia, the advantage of ethnic federalism is not vitally essential for all Ethiopians other than for some narrow cliques. That was why the regime of narrow cliques of Ethiopia lacks considerable recognition from its inception. If we delve into the causes of the imminent underlying current unrest in Ethiopia, the leading root of this strife is ethnic federalism, though the narrow clique has named ethnic federalism saying ‘right to self-administration, secession, blah-blah’.

Ethnic-centered administration has severely damaged Ethiopia. The system has empowered deliberate ethnic schisms among the peoples of Ethiopia. It is impossible to have an appropriate process of nation-building once you have institutionalized ethnic schism on the authority of pretentious federalism. Taking everything into account, the system of ethnic federalism applied in Ethiopia for the past 20 years and more by the narrow clique is bankrupted now. In our language it is called ‘game over’. And Ethiopians have said ‘enough’.

Badme and its surroundings are still occupied by Ethiopia

Following the uncompromising opposition, Abiy has taken an outstanding and brave decision of embracing a new multi-faceted political reform in Ethiopia. He managed to reform the previous state of play which Ethiopia had faced for years.

It was not unforeseen for us. The narrow clique has worked to create inherent animosity between the peoples of Eritrea and Ethiopia. Surprisingly, the narrow clique that caused enormous harm to the peoples of Ethio-Eritrea has not the sanity of Ethiopianism, despite the fact that it caused irreparable damage on behalf of Ethiopians to the people of Eritrea. Have you examined this scenario thoughtfully?

The politics, approach, and objectives of this narrow clique are disastrous.

And now, disgracefully, this narrow clique is saying that if Abiy’s rapprochement between Eritrea and Ethiopia is rewarding, where is the peace on the ground?

Even though we have made a rapprochement, Badme and its surroundings are still occupied by Ethiopia. This is happening because the narrow clique, which administers the region, is impeding execution of the decision of the border commission as a tactic for its survival.

The situation in Badme is becoming worse and worse ever more. Do you understand why we choose to be tolerant? It is because the narrow clique is exploiting the enduring political unrest in the country. Who is assigning land in Badme presently? Why are many houses erecting in Badme? What are the valid laws to distribute the land in Badme, while they are calling for reconciliation with Eritrea?

So, all these disruptive actions of the narrow clique are anti-peace and reconciliation. The narrow clique is taking advantage of the current precarious situation in Ethiopia, the mess of ethnic federalism. This is happening because the narrow clique, along with its bankrupt politics of ethnic federalism, is working against the reform. Consequently, this narrow clique has galvanized extreme confrontation against the uncompleted reform in all directions against Abiy Ahmed.

All in all, the narrow clique is applying full force to invalidate the endeavors of the rapprochement and it has intended essentially to overturn the overall achievements of the ongoing reform in Ethiopia.

With regards to Eritrea, the narrow clique is ploughing a siege mentality in the people, saying you have been encircled in all corners.

As it is remembered, they devised the policy of immigration to weaken Eritrea. There are different sorts of challenges in Ethiopia. For that reason, this narrow clique is carrying out all sorts of tussles with the purpose of hampering healthy relationship between both nations.

That is not scary though. What matters most is the internal conditions of Ethiopia.

Abiy has taken the courageous decision of introducing reform. But, what is he going to do in the end? Once Abiy has achieved his initial objective, we don’t believe everything is solved until we see the last results. We are not saying this because we are extremely genius or anything else. However, our historic experience tells us so.

When you say, ‘I am federalist’, what is federalism?

How are we going to achieve lasting results? How are we going to bring sustainable peace and cooperation? Peace comes through real work. Peace prevails through genuine solidarity. This is not the issue of border conflict. That is not our challenge. There are other external powers who are jointly working with the narrow clique of Ethiopia to hurt Eritrea. If we fail to frame a strong foundation for the enduring reform in Ethiopia, we can be victims of political turmoil stemming from Ethiopia. We don’t want to fully interfere in deciphering the poisons of ethnic federalism. That is their internal issue. However, we won’t be silent until it victimizes Eritrea and that is why we are working together with Abiy Ahmed.

We need not say everything is going to be solved in view of the present reform as we would be politically naïve and gullible. We know that apart from the conflict-ridden interest of the internal narrow cliques, external forces are working hard to disrupt the situation. We will seriously scrutinize their engagements. All these forces are partaking in the internal affairs of Ethiopia. Nonetheless, the most dangerous political threat is the precarious internal unsteadiness of Ethiopia. It is easy to spread hatred. But it is difficult to bring peace by neutralizing hatred.

Ethnic polarization has reached in its peak. It won’t be easily cured by means of a single remedy. We need not to discern it as an ordinary conflict. New scenarios are emerging every time. These ultimatums are altering their characteristics constantly.

Yet, our cooperation and solidarity won’t be troubled, rather it is increasingly hardening. We may encounter some daunting actions; yet we won’t change our relationship with Ethiopia.

One of the contested matters in Ethiopia presently is the issue of election. This is according to the traditional culture of politics. This is not a worthy issue by itself. It will hinder the attention of the government on the other important issues of the country, if the disagreement on matters of election becomes more to the fore. There are many actors in this election. If we need genuine political transformation, we should consider the issues properly. There are experienced international institutions knowledgeable in research. These institutions are analyzing the situation poorly, exploiting the situation.

We can defend ourselves for any potential conflict coming out from Ethiopia. However, Ethiopia is a big nation. It has its own significant role in our region.

All internal political powers are propagating very shallow judgements.  When you say, ‘I am federalist’, what is federalism? When you say ‘I am unionist’, what is unionist? I am highlighting the difficulties of the situation. We can alleviate the bad consequences of ethnic federalism if we study the problem properly.

Dear President, after the new leadership came to power in Ethiopia, it appears the former political structure is fundamentally reforming. Taking into consideration all these emerging scenarios, along with the signed rapprochement, what are their influence on Eritrea and our region according to your perspective?

In our history, the nation causing the main threat for Eritrea is Ethiopia. We have direct interests Ethiopia. We are not saying we will interfere in the internal affairs of Ethiopia. That is not the point. However, the condition of Ethiopia is directly of concern to us. We forecasted the existing scenario of Ethiopia.

I was invited to participate in the conference of 1992 where the current system of ethnic federalism was considered to be implemented.  The present-day enduring strife among tribes of Ethiopia was imbedded back in that time. It has institutionally evolved for almost 30 years.

We have advised the narrow cliques, forecasting this sort of ethnic polarization. I have had the chance to look at the system of ethnic federalism before anyone was allowed to study it. I have read it twice and I was asked to give my recommendations. For the sake of secession, you should not make the society into an ethnically polarized community. I warned them not to implement such a system.

We haven’t any border problem. We don’t demarcate the borders. We have already inherited the demarcated borders. There were external forces who have encouraged the narrow clique to divide and rule Ethiopia through ethnic federalism. The people of Ethiopia were not part of the war against us. It was the interest of the narrow clique. This narrow ethnic polarization has only one way in the end. That end is devastation.

There are many elites who define this scenario, saying it is the rights of nations, nationalities and peoples. And then these elites deceive the people for their political benefit. As I have said in 1994, how are you going to accommodate the challenges of the current ethnic federalism? It is not possible to continue while you are creating a rift in communities. You cannot even walk through all these narrow positions.

We can look at situations of Iraq, Somalia, Sudan, and others. These nations are living through ethnic polarization. Where are they right now? All are engulfed in civil war. Ethiopia is not different from any nation of the world. That excuse of ‘we are the country of nation nationalities and peoples’ won’t work at all.

We are advising Ethiopians to follow the best path for nation building. This is not because we fear any force coming out from Ethiopia. We can defend ourselves efficiently. I don’t want to suggest this way or that way. The people should select the right way. The people are the last victims. The key problematic force inside Ethiopia presently is the clique of ethnic politics.

Dear President, how do you analyze the role of the people in protecting Eritrea within these three generations and what will be its impacts in the future?

Pertaining to struggle of people of Eritrea, I am always amazed by the firm doggedness of the people although I am part of the struggle for decades. I sometime even ask myself will other people be able to carry such a burden and ultimately triumph.

The forte of our people is to triumph due to its unrelenting struggle. After the Second World War, Eritrea was considered as a main target. To control Eritrea, the powers devised to divide and rule the people of Eritrea. The people have crossed that precarious time and then the civil war, the challenge, has helped our people to figure out the political dynamics. We have learned a lot of experience from our previous challenges.

If we compare with our surroundings, we are all equal people.  But, we should ask why all these burdens and challenges against the people of Eritrea. However, the people have defeated all its challenges. This culture of gallantry should be preserved. This is the grace of our nation.

Follow us on Twitter @EthiopiaInsight and join our Telegram channel here

If you have suggestions to improve the translation, please contact us.

Editor: William Davison

Main photo: President Isaias Afewerki with Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed, March 3, 2019, Ethiopian Office of the Prime Minister.

Query or correction? Email us

Published under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence. Cite Ethiopia Insight and link to this page if republished. 

Related Insight

Fe. 2, 2020, What now for Ethiopia’s multinational federation?

Nov. 3, 2019 Liberal democracy is no liberator

Aug. 18, 2019 Federalist façade for centralist front

Feb. 12, 2019 Ethiopia uncorked

Jan. 10, 2019 Ethiopia’s federation needs reviving, not reconfiguring

We need your support to deliver news from across Ethiopia

Please help fund an Ethiopia Insight reporter

About the author

Getachew Gebrekiros Temare

Getachew has a law degree and is a graduate student of conflict resolution. He is a human-rights defender and is active on the rights of disabled people.

9 Comments

  • Wow, where to begin?

    1. Never mind that EPLF is the first political group that created the fictional narrative of Eritrea being colonized by Ethiopia, ethnicized its attack against the nation, and made Amara bashing part and parcel of its ‘independence’ ideology.
    2. Never mind that EPLF willed TPLF into existence in its own image and further promulgated the fiction that Amara is a colonial force to be defeated … for 30 + years.
    3. Never mind that after TPLF and EPLF toppled the Derg, Eritrean leadership fomented ethnic division, and violence within Ethiopia.
    4. Never mind that the weakening of Ethiopia along ethnic lines was an objective of Eritrean leadership in its vision to build a new Eritrea (Singapore style) on the ashes of Ethiopia.

    As if ethnic division and fragmenting Ethiopia along linguistic lines was not the singular objective of Isayas’ led EPLF, he now has the audacity to say he believed the opposite all along ;and deigns to tell us with a straight face, that he bleeds for what ethnic federalism has wrought in today’s Ethiopia.

    Whatever his game, President Isayas’ singular obsession is TPLF and in that he has sadly found an ally in PM Abiy. That PM Abiy joins President Isayas to bash TPLF is not only sad but reckless beyond measure. It only serves to further alienate people of Tigray from the rest of the country. Because, as everyone knows, there is no real peace without involving the people that are immediately impacted at the border, who at the moment, for better or for worse, are led by TPLF. So far PM Abiy has completely side-stepped the people of Tigray in his peace-making initiative with Eritrea. They are nowhere to be seen or heard from. Can one stop for a second and imagine how odd that really is?

    Anything that PM Abiy does without involving the leadership of Tigray is a sinister game, certainly not aimed at achieving peace but pure consolidation of power. The rest of us looking on, therefore, should not be fooled with this backyard game of power. We should hold these leaders accountable by asking what will be done on the ground and force them to state the concessions they are going to make. Let’s not be taken by the pubic stunts and lofty speeches they make.

  • Isayas Afewerki has turned Eritrea into African North Korea. He is ruling the country without law or constitution. There are more than 300 prisons, young ppl forced to serve in the armee for decades.
    How is this guy supposed to teach his neighbours democracy? He wants to be the boss in the Horn of Africa. Fortunately he is too old and too weak.

  • Eritrea is irrelevant in securing a peaceful and prosperous Ethiopia,last 27 years is evident of the fact how irrelevant Eritrea is despite the fact it is a neighboring country with an outlet to the sea,I think this article is garbage and lacks a broad insight analysis of east African politics, Ethnic federalism ( with all its short comings) proved to be working especially for Ethiopia, those with difficulty to understand and argue against it are narrow chauvinists trying to impose their hegemony.

  • Yup, ethnic federalism is a cancel. Especially in east Africa, which is home to more than 100 different ethnic groups. And, a cancer needs to be removed by any means necessary before metastasize and take down the host. Certainly will not stop at ethnic level, will cascade down to sub-ethnic groups to tribe to clan to sub clan to family to … it’s a way to a certain death!

    Federalism is fare, but not ethnic based federalism, where each ethnic group curves it’s own territory. In time, horrible fights as the sub groups, tribes and clans within the same ethnic group would want to curve own territories. Ethnic federalism is the way to hell!

    • This is all garbage. The person who is taking is nothing but a criminal and a dictator! I even hate calling his name!
      He jailed my uncle with out any trial since 2002 for NO reason and we still have no clue where he is about!

      This guy need to be hunted and arrested!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.